and Its Modes, On Human Conduct, and On His tory and other essays. Some. poses are close to embarrassing, such as the ‘Peace with Germany’, while. others are close to exqu isite On History and Other Essays: Author: Michael Oakeshott: Edition: 2, illustrated, reprint: Publisher: Liberty Fund, ISBN: , Length: pages: Subjects On History and Other Essays. In five essays, including three on historiography, one of the greatest minds in English political thought in the twentieth century explores themes central to the human experience: the nature of history, the rule of law, and the quest for power that is /5
On History and Other Essays by Michael Oakeshott
Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Want to Read saving…. Want to Read Currently Reading Read. Other editions. Enlarge cover. Error rating book. Refresh and try again. Open Preview See a Problem? Details if other :. Thanks for telling us about the problem. Return to Book Page. Preview — On History and Other Essays by Michael Oakeshott. On History and Other Essays by Michael Oakeshott.
In five essays, including three on historiography, one of the greatest minds in English political thought in the twentieth century explores themes central to the human experience: the nature of history, the rule of law, and the quest for power that is intrinsic to the human condition. Get A Copy. Paperbackpages. Published November 11th by Liberty Fund Inc, on history and other essays. first published More Details Original Title. Other Editions 3. All Editions Add a New Edition Combine, on history and other essays.
Friend Reviews. To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up. To ask other readers questions about On History and Other Essaysplease sign up. Be the first to ask a question about On History and Other Essays. Lists with This Book. This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list ». Community Reviews. Showing Average rating 3. Rating details. More filters. Sort order. Start your review of On History and Other Essays. Nov 29, Marc rated it it was ok Shelves: historiography.
This was a much more philosophical book than I had expected. Michael Oakeshott is not a well-known name, but apparently 'connoisseurs' still place him in the top of 20th century philosophy and political theory.
In this late work he deals in a very abstract way with the possibility of historical research. So, this book is essentially about epistemology what are the conditions to come to real knowledge? Oakeshott mainly focuses on how th This was a much more philosophical book than I had expected.
Oakeshott mainly focuses on how things should NOT be done in historical research, and what the pitfalls are in which historians keep on falling. That means that in the end, you will be left with the question whether sound historical research indeed is possible. Oakeshott is convinced it is, but does not offer clear answers. flag 9 likes · Like · see review, on history and other essays. Nov 29, Sense of History rated it it was ok Shelves: philosophy-of-historythe-writing-of-historytheory-of-history.
By insiders the British philosopher Michael Oakeshott is placed at the same height as Wittgenstein and Heidegger, as brilliant and genially as they were, on history and other essays, but equally hermetic and elusive.
In recent years his thinking has been extensively recuperated by neoconservative thinkers, because he was very active in the field of political theory. In all his work a fierce critique on rationalism and modernism stands out, but I hesitate to just call him a conservative or reactionary thinker.
My By insiders the British philosopher Michael Oakeshott is placed at the same height as Wittgenstein and Heidegger, as brilliant and genially as they were, but equally hermetic and elusive.
My impression is that he just wanted to be thorough and get to the bottom of things, dismissing wrong concepts, views and theories. That is also what he does in this book. Oakeshott devotes a great deal of time to making precise, meticulous distinctions between terms and concepts historical past, practical past, encapsulated past, historical inquiry, occurrence, event, change, identity, continuity, etc. and does this in a very abstract way, that requires a lot of effort from on history and other essays reader and I have to admit that some passages were almost impossible for me to follow.
In these essays on history, Oakeshott primordially asks himself what history or the past really is. He makes a radical distinction between the practical and the historical past. Moreover, we usually deal with those relicts very practically, with a usefulness that is only relevant for the present and the future. In fact, a historical approach can only say something meaningful about the past if it completely distances itself from that practical relevance for present and future, and that is an extremely difficult task.
Oakeshott barely discusses the way in which such an enquiry is possible. He rather devotes his energy to refuting methods that he believes are radically wrong: for example approaching the past from a contemporary question, or from a theory or model, on history and other essays, or - even worse - from a teleological perspective in which what precedes is derived from the result.
The use of causality, on history and other essays, comparisons, correlations and analogies is also defined by him as deficient sometimes in very blunt terms. Oakeshott is very strict about this and shows in detail on history and other essays pitfalls of these approaches, and above all that they have nothing to do with the past, but everything with the present and the future. When reading these essays, on history and other essays, the question arises of course whether Oakeshott considers real historical research possible at all.
He certainly answers this question positively, on history and other essays, but he gives so many restrictions that hardly anything remains for those who practice history research in reality. So, should we just push him aside and declare what he says irrelevant? I do not think so. Because what he writes actually makes sense.
While reading these essays, for example, I noticed that his elaboration on the distinction between practical and historical past comes very close to the temporality theories that were developed much later by Reinhart Koselleck and François Hartog. And his accent on the constructivist character of historical approaches almost directly leads to the postmodernism of, among others, Frank Ankersmit.
In that sense, Oakeshott may be comparable to a fierce weedkiller, whose work benefits on history and other essays to harvest. His essays are certainly worth the effort, but definitely also tough reading.
flag 4 likes · Like · see review. Oct 30, Simon rated it liked it Shelves: phd-readingphilosophy. I read the three essays which make up 'On History'. Oakeshott is a careful thinker. This makes him hard work, but he is worth your time, especially if you want to think about the nature of on history and other essays enquiry.
flag Like · see review. David rated it it was amazing Sep 15, Levan Ramishvili rated it it was amazing Nov 27, Ruru Ghoshal rated it it was amazing Jun 17, Flores rated it really liked it Nov 24, Duncan Brown rated it it was amazing Sep 07, Toby Paterson rated it liked it Oct 18, Eric rated it it was amazing Oct 15, David Sampaio rated it liked it Apr 27, Hexun rated it really liked it Apr 28, Dominic rated it liked it Jun 10, Dan rated it liked it Oct 02, William Cole rated it liked it Jul 10, Tom rated it really liked it Nov 02, Gulsen rated it really liked on history and other essays Jul on history and other essays, Paul Petides rated it really liked it Jul 16, Ricardo Migueis rated it liked it Jan 03, Seth rated it it was amazing Aug 29, Joseph rated it it was amazing Aug 01, Merrell Denison rated it it was amazing Oct 21, Rtgr vn Dngn rated it really liked it Jun 16, Justin rated it really liked it Aug 06,
Edward Said - Reflections on Exile and Other Essays
, time: 57:10On History and Other Essays - Liberty Fund
On History and Other Essays: Author: Michael Oakeshott: Edition: 2, illustrated, reprint: Publisher: Liberty Fund, ISBN: , Length: pages: Subjects “In this book’s first three essays, Professor Michael Oakeshott sets out to establish the nature, conditions, and limits of historical inquiry, but, for once, professional historians may find that a philosopher has explained their work and unique contribution to human On History and Other Essays. In five essays, including three on historiography, one of the greatest minds in English political thought in the twentieth century explores themes central to the human experience: the nature of history, the rule of law, and the quest for power that is /5
No comments:
Post a Comment